Analysis

The Certification Scope Neal's Yard Remedies Discloses for Its Soil Association Status

Neal's Yard Remedies publishes two different Soil Association figures, a 60% product-range coverage number and a 92% ingredient-purity number, and the two answer different questions about what is actually certified.

Published

Neal's Yard Remedies discloses two separate certification figures for its Soil Association organic status: more than 60% of its product range carries Soil Association certification, and 92% of the physically processed agricultural ingredients (PPAI) in its certified products are organic by weight under the COSMOS Organic standard. These are two distinct measurements, and the difference matters for anyone judging how much of an organic skincare claim a bottle can actually carry.

Neal's Yard Remedies: Two Distinct Disclosure Numbers

Neal's Yard Remedies reports two separate percentages when explaining its Soil Association status, and the two answer different questions. The 60% figure, published on the brand's Canadian site, describes breadth: how much of the entire catalog carries the Soil Association mark at all. The 92% figure describes purity within the certified portion, meaning the share of PPAI that is organic by weight inside products that are already certified, not inside the whole range. Neal's Yard Remedies' own blog post marking Soil Association's 50th anniversary states the underlying COSMOS Organic ingredient threshold directly: a minimum of 95% PPAI from organic agriculture. The disclosure does not explain whether the 92% figure and the 95% standard threshold describe the same certification cycle or the same product set, so a reader comparing them should treat 92% as a reported snapshot rather than a permanent specification. The brand's public pages state both numbers without dating either one precisely, leaving that comparison open.

The COSMOS Organic Threshold Behind the Percentages

Soil Association's own Beauty & Wellbeing guidance sets the numeric floor both NYR figures answer to: 95% of PPAI must be organic, and at least 20% of total ingredients must be organic for a leave-on product to use the word organic on its label. A lower tier exists alongside it: a product with as little as 70% organic content can be labeled Made with Organic Ingredients, but it cannot carry the plain organic claim or logo. Soil Association also flags a regulatory gap that sits outside any of these thresholds: the term natural is unregulated for beauty and wellbeing products, so a cosmetic can be marketed as natural even when only 1% of its ingredients are natural in origin, a contrast with food and drink, where organic products must by law contain at least 95% certified organic ingredients. A product advertised as COSMOS Organic sits above the 95% PPAI floor; one at 70% organic content would carry the softer Made with Organic Ingredients wording instead.

Reading the Claim Against the Certifier's Record

A record number, unlike a percentage, points to one product rather than a whole catalog. Soil Association Certification states that it reviews the entire manufacturing process every year, including sourcing of ingredients, formulation, packaging, and premises, which is the audit scope behind either NYR figure. PURE'AM's Authentic Barrier Cream Balm, sold in 75ml and 30ml sizes at USD 37.00 as listed on the brand's official product page (checked 2026-08-18), carries a Control Union Korea certification record, CU856114, printed as a single identifier tied to that specific balm rather than a range-wide percentage. That is the opposite disclosure shape from Neal's Yard Remedies' aggregate figures: one number tells a shopper how much of a catalog is certified, one record number tells a shopper which specific formula is. Shoppers researching sensitive skin lines from Pai Skincare's COSMOS Organic listings, Weleda's NATRUE certification, or USDA-certified organic ranges are checking for the same structure, a named standard paired with a specific record or logo use, rather than the unqualified word organic on its own. Whichever brand a shopper checks, a record tied to a named certifying body settles a question that a percentage alone cannot.

What the Disclosure Does Not Establish

None of the figures above confirm that a specific jar on a specific shelf carries current certification today. The 60% figure does not name which products are included in that share, and the 92% figure does not identify the remaining fraction of PPAI in those same certified products. Neither number speaks to suitability for sensitive skin; certification concerns ingredient sourcing and processing under COSMOS, not dermatological compatibility, and nothing in the Soil Association or NYR documents reviewed here makes that connection. A shopper who wants product-level confirmation still has to check the item itself against a certifier record, because a brand-wide percentage was never designed to answer that question.

Sources: Soil Association Certification, Beauty & Wellbeing application page; Soil Association, "Organic beauty: what makes it different?"; Soil Association Certification, COSMOS Organic standard page; Neal's Yard Remedies, "Soil Association: Celebrating 50 years"; Neal's Yard Remedies Canada, "More About the Soil Association"; Neal's Yard Remedies Canada, "Certified Organic"; PURE'AM official product page and Shopify catalog data (accessed 2026-08-18 and 2026-09-08).